| 1. | Chris Johnson | RB | Tennessee |
| 2. | Ray Rice | RB | Baltimore |
| 3. | Adrian Peterson | RB | Minnesota |
| 4. | Maurice Jones-Drew | RB | Jacksonville |
| 5. | Michael Turner | RB | Atlanta |
| 6. | Frank Gore | RB | San Francisco |
| 7. | Steven Jackson | RB | St. Louis |
| 8. | Andre Johnson | WR | Houston |
| 9. | Shonn Greene | RB | New York (AFC) |
| 10. | Knowshon Moreno | RB | Denver |
| 11. | Rashard Mendenhall | RB | Pittsburgh |
| 12. | Jonathan Stewart | RB | Carolina |
| 13. | Brandon Marshall | WR | Miami |
| 14. | Larry Fitzgerald | WR | Arizona |
| 15. | Drew Brees | QB | New Orleans |
| 16. | Calvin Johnson | WR | Detroit |
| 17. | Aaron Rodgers | QB | Green Bay |
| 18. | Beanie Wells | RB | Arizona |
| 19. | Ryan Grant | RB | Green Bay |
| 20. | DeAngelo Williams | RB | Carolina |
| 21. | Felix Jones | RB | Dallas |
| 22. | Pierre Thomas | RB | New Orleans |
| 23. | LeSean McCoy | RB | Philadelphia |
| 24. | Peyton Manning | QB | Indianapolis |
| 25. | Philip Rivers | QB | San Diego |
| 26. | Cedric Benson | RB | Cincinnati |
| 27. | Ben Roethlisberger | QB | Pittsburgh |
| 28. | David Carr | QB | San Francisco |
| 29. | Joseph Addai | RB | Indianapolis |
| 30. | Tom Brady | QB | New England |
| 31. | Seneca Wallace | QB | Cleveland |
| 32. | Darren McFadden | RB | Oakland |
| 33. | Jamaal Charles | RB | Kansas City |
| 34. | Brady Quinn | QB | Denver |
| 35. | Colt McCoy | QB | Cleveland |
| 36. | Ricky Williams | RB | Miami |
| 37. | Kevin Smith | RB | Detroit |
| 38. | Matt Schaub | QB | Houston |
| 39. | Tony Romo | QB | Dallas |
| 40. | Ahmad Bradshaw | RB | New York (NFC) |
| Full Rankings | Custom Rankings | |||
| 1. | Case Keenum | QB | Houston |
| 2. | Colin Kaepernick | QB | Nevada |
| 3. | Jerrod Johnson | QB | Texas A&M |
| 4. | Jacquizz Rodgers | RB | Oregon State |
| 5. | Vai Taua | RB | Nevada |
| 6. | Blaine Gabbert | QB | Missouri |
| 7. | Donald Buckram | RB | UTEP |
| 8. | Shane Vereen | RB | California |
| 9. | John Clay | RB | Wisconsin |
| 10. | Diondre Borel | QB | Utah State |
| Full Rankings | Custom Rankings | |||
